But there is a huge disagreement between sunnis and shia scholars on mutah marriages, as per sunni scholars mutah was permitted in prophet pbuhs era but later it declared prohibited. Islam stack exchange is a question and answer site for muslims, experts in islam, and those interested in learning more about islam. Also you can see the prophet saying mutah is haram in other hadiths such as this in buhkary, these 2 hadiths one in muslim and another one here, and last hadith in abu dawud. Inside nigerias unholy war paperback march 30, 2016 by mike smith author 4. Its hard to know what the question is asking because the term haram is used for issues of practice not beliefs. It is sad that the shia elders use false rhetoric to demand that their followers reject logic and morality, to instead blindly.
What is a list of haram things shia muslims believe. The misuse of shia hadeeth to demonstrate the prohibition. However, since shias believe that allah swt cannot do wrong and his actions are aslah most beneficial, everything has a purpose. Ghusl for touching a dead body the obligation to give ghusl. Shia sunni a truetube ctvc film directed by adam tyler bafta nominated, short educational film exploring the religious differences and commonalities between two sects in islam. We have designed this app especially for muslims all over the world who are fond of reading. It is a shia islamic belief based on several hadith found in above mentioned books, that there are several other books which are always under possession of current imam, these books are never in possessions of people. There is evidence in the books of the history and the cultural traditions of the arabs that in certain situations, a temporary marital relationship between a man and a woman was considered to be acceptable among pre. Much of the debate revolves around whether a temporary marriage is moral or not. Just because proponents of mutah dismiss them does not mean that they are not worth considering as credible evidence against mutah.
Marriage mutah in shia and sunni islam where mutah or temporary marriage is a. May 22, 2010 im aware mutah marriage is permissible within shia sect but just curious to hear your views towards it and i would like to hear your views towards sunni stance on mutah marriages. This website contains a well sorted collection of shia books you can find hundreds of books on shia community. Tahqeeq halal o haram mutah aur islam reading online, free books, islam. Mutah an alternative shia perspective book references. The gharab al quran, the dictionary of quranic terms states.
These books include hand written quran by imam ali murtada, jafr, jabr and mushaf fatima codex of fatima. In fact, the shia books of fiqh contain a section entitled the loaning of vaginas. Urdu shia books miscellaneous books shia multimedia. Most shia of today have a hard time selfjustifying the concept of mutah. Dehshat gardi aur fitna e khawarij download urdu book islamic tube free. Thereby, proving mutah from sunni sources does not absolve the shia from explaining the moral lapse in the shia imams who would declare such an act to be highly recommended. Aug 07, 2010 sister, it depends on our intentions niat if you want stay away from zina, you may do mutah in legal way and dont follow the shaitans whisper. Mutah temporary marriage completion of argument al.
Tauzih ul masail is an amazing app that contains a book named tauzeeh al masail with urdu translation. Tahqeeq halal o haram mutah aur islam haram, reading online. Prophet made mutah haram on the day of khayber book of tahdeeb. Flowing out of blood of a slaughtered animal in a normal quantity. These books can be best read by adobe acrobat reader or smartly read in apple ipadipodiphone using ibooks application. A misyar marriage is a unique sunni muslim innovation. Of course, there are a few issues of beliefstheology that sunni muslims object to, but ive never heard any of my sunni religious te. Shia books of hadith ahaadith, narrations welcome to shia. This is what islam says about nikah mutah temporary marriage. The people of faith are in agreement that mutah is halaal, then a great man said mut ah was. Oct 24, 2008 according to my information mutah was halal during the time of prophet p. Dec, 2011 most shia of today have a hard time selfjustifying the concept of mutah. Muta disambiguation this disambiguation page lists articles associated with the title mutah.
Why would umar ra prohibit this marriage if it was already known that mutah is haram. Taijani samavi it means the mutah marirage nikah, or unpermanent marriage, or temporary marriage to a determined term. However when discussing with shia men or women, all of them always get offended when asked how many times they have done it with other shia men or women. Engineer muhammad ali mirza official channel 947,301 views 33. The book can also be downloaded from the following salafi link. The misuse of shia hadeeth to demonstrate the prohibition of.
Whoever says mutah is only halal under extreme circumstances is adopting a shadh view which does not represent the sayings of the greats amongst our. Mutah means to marry a lady for a prescribed period of time, and this is forbidden and haraam according to all the four madhabs. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. This means by talking only about two sahabas will not make mutah halal in sunni fiqh. Nikah mutah, a temporary marriage in some branches of shia islam. Misyar marriage is defined as an official marital relationship between a man and a woman who do not live together, and where the husband is not financially responsible for a misyar wife. In fact, it is a point which causes many of them to doubt their faith, and rightfully so. Shia booksi love booksbooks to readfree pdf booksreading onlinethe 100 my loveislamicgoal. In brief, mutah is a temporary contract, which is a way of passing ones time just like a temporary contract with a prostitute.
Muta marriage is valid type of marriage in shia jurisprudence. It is sad that the shia elders use false rhetoric to demand that their followers reject logic and morality, to instead blindly accept the idea that prostitution is part of islam. Dec 18, 2010 muta marriage is valid type of marriage in shia jurisprudence. The following are a few examples of ahadith from shia texts that have survived over the centuries when so much has been doctored. The contents of these books are taken from the 8th to the th century 2nd to 7th century of islam. The normal trend is to dismiss these narrations which are never quoted in books that justify mutah. Misyar can be a temporary arrangement, but unlike the muta marriage, which ends on the expiration date of the contract, the misyar has no certain date. These books seek to give a rational account of shi a theology in contrast with the ashari, mutazili and other theological schools of islam. Book on islamic laws islamic laws the official website of the. From the website management narrations about muth in sahih al bukhari narrations about muth in sahih muslim article by dr. Permanent marriage muta marriage or temporary marriage a shia of the male sex may contract a muta marriage with a woman professing the muslim, christian or jewish religion, or even with a woman who is a fireworshiper. Download hubeali islamic calendars archives from year 2006 to 2020. In shia islam there are two kinds of halal marriage, mutah temporary and nikah permanent and each has its own conditions, benefits and limitations.
Mutta marriage or temporary marriage contract in shia islam. It is like the perpetual marriage, as can never be valid but only through a marriage contract. The following are shia hadith from the most important of the four shia books of hadith, alkafi. It is narrated in both bukari and muslim, that ali said. Here we have shia online islamic books in english and urdu. There are more forensics to prove that mutah was not considered legitimate by the ahlul baith. The debate on the permissibility of mutah marriages has spanned through centuries. I would like to know who made mutah haram after the death of prophet p. There a lot of hadith in shia books that say that imams forbade mutah.
Surah talaq of the quran stipulates that there is no such thing as an impromptu triple. Mutta marriage or temporary marriage contract in shia. Much of this discussion is whether the practice of mutah is halal according to islamic tenets. It is perplexing that the shia scholars of hadith would use terminology i. Allah has allowed mutah in quran, whereas sunnis follow umars sunnah who made it haram. List of ahadith saying that it was prophet mohammad pbuh who banned muta. Mutah is an old islamic practice for the men who used to travel long distances and needed someone to please with. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading nikah al mutah zina or sunnah. We would like to know if there is anything in the shia faith that prevents such a marriage. Hubeali asws is a charity organisation committed to propagate the true teachings of ahl albaytasws. Jun 09, 20 from the website management narrations about muth in sahih al bukhari narrations about muth in sahih muslim article by dr. It is recommended that if you dont already have it you download. However, at the end of his caliphate, he made it haram.
The official website of the office of his eminence alsayyid. Books hubeali asws online shia islamic articles, books. The very act of indulging in a temporary marriage has triggered a multitude of emotional reactions from muslims and nonmuslims alike. Dr zakir naik videosdr zakir naik, dr zakir naik answers, dr zakir naik videos, dr zakir naik lectures, dr zakir naik urdu, dr zakir naik 2016, dr zakir naik english, dr zakir naik hindi, dr zakir naik bayan,books written by dr zakir naikdr zakir naik speech in englishislamic zakir naikdr zakir videozakir naik childrendr zakir naik. Had ali ibn abi talib as really forbidden mutah to ibn abbas, then is it believable that. That makes it haram plus is it ok if a sunni sheikh performs the wedding contract. It refers to the shia belief in temporary marriage in which a man pays a woman and it becomes permissible for the man to have sexual relations with her for a fixed period of time. Conclusion the fact of the matter is that the ahlus sunnah considers mutah to be haram forbidden, and believes this prohibition to be from the prophet. Is it not better in this situation that they recite the seegha for mutah in the hope that it is acceptable to allah. Also you can see the prophet saying mutah is haram in other hadiths such as this in buhkary, these 2. In the shia context, mutah refers to a temporary marriage. Jul 05, 2010 mutah translates literally to pleasure in arabic. Mutah is arabic word which means enjoyment or pleasure.
Mar 30, 20 shia dont rely on sunni hadith books sahih bukhari, sahih muslim etc, shia have several reasons as to why sunni hadith books are rejected. It is sad that the shia elders use false rhetoric to demand that their followers reject logic and morality. If either a wild or domesticated animal whose meat is lawful. O mankind, indeed we have created you from male and female and made you peoples and tribes that you may know one another. Similar rules that apply for nikah apply for mutah if certain types of women are haram for a man to contract nikah then the same rule applies with mutah. Mutah na kijiye books free download pdf, pdf books reading. Indeed, the most noble of you in the sight of allah is the most righteous of you. Sunnis, have six major authentic sihaa sitta hadith books and several others to their list which are secondary on level in their collection. In shia fiqh mutah is shamefull act for pure sayed family. The name of books are links to the books, so just click these, and you will be taken to the desired book. These books include discussions about theology taw. A man cannot contract mutah with a married women, as is the case with a normal other rules along this line are stipulated in our books of fiqh, which will be discussed in the.